Short answer: The Bucket of Blood in Phillack (4.6 from 1,215 Google reviews) is the best-loved pub in Hayle for atmosphere, and Angarrack Inn (4.7 from 747) is the one for food. The Watermill at Griggs Quay has the best family garden. Most Hayle pubs welcome dogs, but book if you want to eat.
Hayle does not have one pub street. It has pubs scattered along a three-mile line from Phillack church in the east to the estuary quays in the west, with one up a valley at Angarrack and one on the dunes at Gwithian. That matters when you choose the best pubs in Hayle, because a ten-minute drive can be the difference between a low-beamed bar with a legend and a riverside garden with a play area. This guide sorts them by what you want from the evening, and flags the catches visitors mention.
Rated 4.6 from 1,215 Google reviews, this is the one most visitors are told to find. It sits beside Phillack church on the road to the Towans, and the building is Grade II listed, with the oldest parts dating from the late 13th or early 14th century, according to Wikipedia. The name comes from folklore: a landlord is said to have drawn a bucket of blood from the well, which turned out to hold the body of a murdered customs officer. One less dramatic theory is red water from tin mining run-off. The well is still by the pub. It is owned by St Austell Brewery, so expect their ales on the pumps. Reviewers praise the low ceilings, the welcome and the food, and say it is dog friendly. It is small, and several reviewers say to book if you want to eat.
One thing to check: Visit St Ives lists food on Wednesday to Saturday at lunch and in the evening, plus Sunday from 1pm, while CAMRA's entry says the kitchen shuts from November to Easter. The two disagree, so ring the pub on 01736 697824 before you plan a winter meal around it.
The east end of town, by Copperhouse Pool, has the roughest-and-readiest bar in Hayle and the most going on. It scores 4.1 from 372 Google reviews, lower than the rest of this list, with reviewers mentioning tired toilets. In its favour: low beams, a dog bar mentioned by reviewers, a pool table, dartboards and a garden for children. CAMRA's entry mentions live music at weekends and a midweek quiz, so ask what is on. It is a place for a loud, cheap night rather than a quiet dinner.
Angarrack is a village at the head of the creek, a mile or so inland, and the pub is the highest-rated in this guide: 4.7 from 747 Google reviews. Reviewers single out homemade pies, a moussaka, lasagne, and a Sunday roast with bread and butter pudding to follow. CAMRA's entry lists cask ales including a guest from a Cornish brewer, tables outside and a beer garden across the car park, and describes the pub as dog friendly. Reviewers call it independently owned. Several reviewers say to book in the season. It is also the pub you want in December, when Angarrack's famous Christmas lights are on. Our Angarrack Christmas lights guide covers parking.
The Cornish Arms (4.3 from 1,165 Google reviews) is the town-centre option, and it is known for its Sunday roast. Reviewers describe roast topside with a large Yorkshire pudding and cauliflower cheese, and several mention it is very dog friendly. CAMRA's entry lists St Austell ales, a real fire, a covered garden and live music. One reviewer found it expensive, so check the menu. For the full roast comparison, see our Hayle Sunday roast guide.
Not in Hayle proper, but the pub people drive to after the beach. It has 4.4 from 509 Google reviews and mostly Cornish beer, and CAMRA describes a gastropub linked to an adjacent Asian kitchen, with dogs welcome and no TV in the bar. The catch from reviews: one visitor was told food was for pre-booked tables only, so book rather than assume.
This is the family choice (4.4 from 1,419 Google reviews). Reviewers describe a beer garden with a stream running through it, two bridges, a play area with a slide and some woodland. Inside, one reviewer mentions the original mechanical parts of the old mill. The warning is parking: several reviewers call the car park very small and awkward. Arrive early, or park nearby and walk. Dogs are welcome according to reviewers.
A few hundred metres along the estuary, with views over the RSPB reserve. Rated 4.3 from 1,483 Google reviews, reviewers mention a carvery, a sun trap garden and rooms. Reviews are mixed on price, with a couple calling it expensive for what arrives, and others enjoying the garden and the staff. Ask about dogs when you book. A wheelchair user wrote that staff were helpful and the carvery was good.
Next door to Paradise Park, 4.5 from 464 Google reviews. Reviewers rate the Smoke Shed food, with beef rib and chicken tenders getting specific praise. Paradise Park's own dog page only mentions guide dogs, so ring the park before bringing a pet (our Paradise Park dog guide has more), but reviewers say the pub welcomes dogs.
Mostly yes. Visit St Ives, CAMRA or reviewers describe the Bucket of Blood, Cornish Arms, Angarrack Inn, Red River Inn, Copper House Inn and Watermill as dog friendly. The sensible approach is to ask when you book, particularly if you want to eat, as some pubs restrict dogs to the bar. After a walk, our off-lead dog beaches in Hayle guide shows where to tire them out first.
Hayle has its own railway station and local buses, so the Copperhouse and Commercial Road pubs are an easy walk or short bus ride. CAMRA notes bus routes 14 and 18 near the Copper House Inn. Angarrack, Gwithian and Griggs Quay are harder: Angarrack is about a mile inland and Gwithian is out on the dunes. If you are planning a night out, a taxi or a designated driver is the realistic plan. The Hayle parking guide covers where to leave the car in town.
If the pub plan is a lunch, pair it with the harbour and estuary on the Hayle town page. If you want a longer evening, our date night in Hayle guide covers the restaurants, and St Ives is close by for a different kind of night.
The Bucket of Blood at Phillack has 4.6 from 1,215 Google reviews and a Grade II listed building with a well that gave it its name. For food, Angarrack Inn is rated 4.7 from 747 Google reviews.
Visit St Ives, CAMRA or reviewers describe the Bucket of Blood, Cornish Arms, Angarrack Inn, Red River Inn, Copper House Inn and Watermill as dog friendly. Ask when booking a table, as some keep dogs to the bar.
The Watermill at Griggs Quay has a stream through its garden, a play area and woodland, according to reviewers. Parking there is small, so arrive early.
Local folklore says a landlord drew a bucket of blood from the pub's well, which held the body of a murdered customs officer. One less dramatic theory is red water from tin mining run-off.
Most do, but the Bucket of Blood's winter food is unclear because listings disagree, so phone the pub on 01736 697824 first. Book ahead at Angarrack Inn and the Red River Inn.
Times, prices and dates are the businesses' and organisers' to change, so check before you travel. Spotted something we've got wrong? Tell us and we'll fix it.
See the full Hayle guide, filtered by who's with you.
Plan your day near Hayle →